Skip to main content

SB 54 Plastic Packaging Resources and Updates. Access Here.

Federal Court Rejects Constitutional Challenge to PACA Trust, Affirms Priority for Unpaid Produce Sellers

November 19, 2026

Federal Court Rejects Constitutional Challenge to PACA Trust, Affirms Priority for Unpaid Produce Sellers

A federal district court has upheld PACA’s trust protections against a constitutional challenge by secured lenders, delivering an important victory for unpaid produce suppliers.

In its November 19 decision in Loeb Term Solutions LLC v. Peterson Farms, Inc., U.S. District Judge Jennifer L. Hall of the District of Delaware affirmed a bankruptcy court judgment recognizing that funds held by a Chapter 7 trustee were PACA trust assets. The ruling confirms that the produce sellers are entitled to payment in full from those assets before the secured lenders receive any distribution.

The dispute arose from the bankruptcy of Something Sweet Acquisition, Inc. and Something Sweet, Inc., manufacturers of baked goods that purchased produce from Peterson Farms and First Call Trading Corp., doing business as The Program. The suppliers were owed approximately $286,000 in principal, plus contractual interest. Following an asset sale and payment of certain administrative expenses, the bankruptcy trustee held approximately $455,000. Two secured lenders claimed those funds under their liens on the companies’ assets.

The court rejected the lenders’ argument that enforcing the PACA trust unconstitutionally took their property without compensation. PACA’s trust provision has existed since 1984, and Something Sweet had operated subject to the trust since at least 2003, well before the lenders extended credit in 2019. Their security interests were therefore subordinate to the produce sellers’ trust rights from the outset.

As Judge Hall explained, “A lender which ignores a decades-old federal statutory trust when underwriting a loan to a produce buyer cannot claim constitutional injury when that trust is enforced as Congress designed.”

The court also upheld the treatment of commingled funds. Produce sellers need not trace their particular produce proceeds into individual assets. Once the applicable trust framework is established, the party claiming that assets fall outside the trust bears the burden of proving it. The lenders’ constitutional challenge to that allocation of proof was forfeited because they had not raised it in the bankruptcy court.

For growers and produce marketers, the decision reinforces a central PACA protection. Qualifying trust assets remain outside the buyer’s bankruptcy estate and must satisfy unpaid produce sellers’ trust claims before becoming available to secured lenders.

Western Growers congratulates June Monroe at Fennemore for securing this significant victory on behalf of Peterson Farms and defending protections that benefit the entire produce industry. Peterson Farms’ counsel also included Joseph H. Huston, Jr. and Gregory T. Donilon of Stevens & Lee. Kate Ellis of McCarron & Diess represented First Call Trading, along with the Stevens & Lee attorneys.